Original part or aftermarket: What really works in everyday practice
An original V-belt for the Diosna SP 24 costs just under
40 euros. An aftermarket version from online retailers costs 12 euros. Choosing
the cheaper option now is understandable, but
not always the right thing to do.
This decision arises in every workshop and
bakery with its own service department several times a month. It is surprisingly
often made incorrectly because the initial question is flawed. It is
not about whether aftermarket parts are generally inferior. It is about
which parts make the difference relevant and which ones
it does not matter for.
Why the question is more difficult than it looks
The term "aftermarket part" is vague. It includes cheap
no-name goods as well as high-quality industrial components that are
manufactured in the same factories as the original parts from well-known
machine manufacturers. Almost everything lies between these two extremes.
In addition, many components sold as "original spare parts"
come from specialized suppliers anyway. Bearings,
belts, seals, and motors are purchased, branded with the company's own logo,
and sold at a markup. In such cases, the
original part is identical to an equivalent aftermarket part, provided
the manufacturer and specifications match.
Where this does not apply, the situation is more complicated. And that is where most mistakes are made.
Parts where aftermarket alternatives work without problems
What connects the following parts: They are standard parts. Their
dimensions, tolerances, and properties are not determined by the
machine manufacturer, but by international standards (DIN,
ISO, EN). The machine builder did not design them, but, like
everyone else, sourced them from a catalog. That is exactly why aftermarket parts
are not a concern here: You are not replacing a manufacturer-specific part,
but buying the same standardized part from a different supplier.
What matters is not the label on the packaging, but the
designation on the part itself.
Ball bearings
Ball bearings are the clearest example. A 6205-2RS with a 25 mm
inner diameter, 52 mm outer diameter, and 15 mm width is a
global standard. The designation itself and the dimensions are standardized in DIN 625 or
ISO 15. From the machine manufacturer's supplier, this
bearing costs between 8 and 14 euros. An equivalent bearing from NSK, NTN, or
a European industrial supplier is in the same price range and
meets the same tolerance classes.
What matters is the full specification, not the name on
the box. Anyone who replaces a C3 bearing with a standard bearing without
C3 clearance has a problem. Anyone who buys the same bearing with
the same designation from another major manufacturer does
not.
V-belts
The same applies to V-belts. A classic
A-profile belt with a defined length is standardized according to DIN 2215 or ISO 4184,
meaning the profile and dimensions are fixed. Qualitative
differences arise from the material (neoprene vs. EPDM) and the
fabric reinforcement, not from the dimensions. For normal
operating conditions in a spiral mixer, high-quality
aftermarket belts from Optibelt or Hutchinson last just as long as the
original part, provided the tension is correct and the pulleys are in good
condition.
The price advantage is real. For a V-belt set on a König bread moulder
you pay about 65 to 80 euros for the original, and 30 to 40 euros for a comparable
industrial belt with the same dimensions and profile data. Over
several machines and a few years, this adds up significantly. V-belts in the shop.
Where original parts are the better choice
Electronic controls and control boards
With electronic assemblies, the calculation changes fundamentally.
Control boards for a WP Matador or a Diosna mixer are
not standard parts. They are matched to the machine software,
the sensors, and the parameters stored at the factory.
Aftermarket boards exist for some models, but compatibility is
difficult to verify, and the failure rate during commissioning
is noticeably higher than with the original part.
To make matters worse, errors caused by incompatible electronics
are often not immediately visible. A machine may initially run and
only produce sporadic failures after weeks, which can hardly be traced back to the
replaced part without a change log.
In such cases, troubleshooting becomes time-consuming and expensive because the
actual cause can no longer be clearly identified. This applies
especially to newer machine models with networked controls, in
which software incompatibilities only occur under certain
operating conditions.
Safety-critical parts
Door switches, emergency stop elements, and safety cover sensors belong
to the few areas where the origin of the parts is not optional.
These parts must be designed for continuous industrial operation
and come with the appropriate certifications, depending on the application, for example
PLd according to EN 13849. Cheap aftermarket parts without traceable
certification may work electrically. Whether they reliably maintain
switching safety in the event of a failure is another question.
This is not a theoretical risk. During an operational inspection or
after an incident, the inspector checks the installed components. A non
certified part in a safety-critical position can
lead to the machine being shut down until the condition is documented
and rectified. The damage caused by production downtime in such
cases far exceeds any previously saved amount.
What the price difference really means
The rule of thumb that has proven itself in practice: You do not pay a high price for standardized
mass-produced parts from the industrial sector if the
specification is identical. Manufacturer-specific assemblies,
safety components, and electronics should be purchased as originals, because the costs
of a subsequent problem quickly outweigh the savings.
For more on how to keep the total operating costs of a bakery machine under control, read the articles Extend the lifespan of bakery machines and Maintenance in daily operations.
How to make the decision systematically
Three questions help to systematize the parts selection before an order is placed.
First: Is the part standardized or
manufacturer-specific? Standardized parts with an ISO designation can be
replaced without problems. Manufacturer-specific parts require more
care when verifying compatibility.
Second: Does the part have a
safety-critical function? If so, only install parts with traceable
certification and documentation. No price advantage
justifies a compromise here.
Third: How high are the consequential costs in the event of an
early failure? A bearing in the auxiliary drive is annoying if it fails after
three months. If the same bearing is located in the main drive of the mixer
and fails in the middle of the night shift, the cost calculation looks
different. The installation position also determines which part quality makes sense.
For bakeries that operate several machines from different manufacturers,
it is worth keeping a short internal list: Which
parts are replaced regularly, which of them are standardized, and which
are not. This saves time with every order and reduces mistakes in
parts selection. How such an approach can be incorporated into a structured
maintenance concept is described in the article Repair instead of repurchase.
Conclusion
The decision between an original part and an aftermarket alternative is not a
matter of principle. It is a case-by-case decision that depends on the
assembly, not on the manufacturer. Anyone who understands this can use the
parts budget effectively without cutting
corners on critical components.
On bakeryparts.com you will find new original spare parts for
common manufacturers, including Diosna, WP Kemper, König, Fortuna, and
Bander. You can find the entire parts inventory here. If you are unsure which part fits your machine, you can use the spare parts request.